Paul Hines:  A Little More To Unspool

I warned you about this yesterday when I wrote:

“his story rolls out … like a 4 a.m. dream that unspools out of sequence.”

So, may I trouble you with just one more story about Paul Hines, the Virginia-born ballplayer who, in 1878, made baseball’s first unassisted triple play?

Providence Grays, 1882

Paul Hines

The story goes that President William McKinley became friends with Hines in the 1870s and later gave Hines his post-baseball job as the Department of Agriculture postmaster.

President William McKinley

But, aside from one mention in Hines’ 1935 obituary, I couldn’t confirm a connection between McKinley and Hines. That Associated Press obituary said they became pals when Hines first played for the Washington Nationals and McKinley was in Congress. But, Hines was long gone from DC and playing in Chicago when McKinley first came to Congress in 1877, so those years don’t jibe.

But, Hines returned to DC and played three more seasons there in the mid-1880s, so, sure, they may have crossed paths.

In 1890, Hines is “looking after a job in the congressional document room,” according to a news report. He continues to play baseball through the mid-1890s, so maybe this is a temporary, or off-season, position.  In any event, maybe McKinley did help him get this low-levelish job.

McKinley loses his congressional seat in 1890 and leaves Washington until 1897, when he returns as President.

Cedar Rapids Gazette, 5/26/1896

Hines is cut from the Burlington Iowa team he is managing in May 1896, and returns to Washington for good.

On the morning of May 24, 1897 Hines is working, in some capacity, in the Old Columbia Law Building at 5th and D Streets, NW.

How do I know this? Because, this happens:

The Washington Times, 5/25/1897

Leonidas Scooffy, a self-described “gentleman of leisure,” and his sister-in-law Miss Willie Lonsdale enter the building and are escorted into the private office of prominent DC lawyer Howe Totten. Scooffy locks the door, brutally assaults the lawyer, takes out a revolver, and threatens to shoot him.

Totten’s cries are heard by his clerks and they rush to help. Hines, who is deaf, doesn’t hear the shouts, but sees the commotion and joins the men in breaking down the locked door.

Hines is credited with helping subdue the assailant.

“Mr. Hines leaped about Scoovey [sic] and with one blow wrenched the pistol away and knocked him to one side of the room,” The Washington Times reported.

Hines is described as “the former baseball player” as his heroism is breathlessly recounted, along with that of the lawyer’s clerks, in Washington’s newspapers.

The Washington Times

Leonidas Scooffy, “Gentleman of Leisure”

Scooffy, whose name is misspelled myriad ways in newspapers, comes from a prosperous California family but has settled in Washington, and it’s believed the incident that spurred the assault stemmed around Scooffy’s young bride.

The couple had eloped just four months earlier and moved to New York. The rumors were that she had, at some point, a relationship with Totten.

We’ll never know for sure. Scooffy tells friends in New York that Totten’s people have come to him to settle the situation “with no further publicity.”  He is indicted by a grand jury in June 1897, but, just as Scooffy predicted, the case is dropped in November.

The Washington Post, 11/16/1897

Scooffy’s wife, who divorces him shortly afterward, becomes an actress of some note, and gets tied up in her own later scandals, while Scooffy, the gentleman of leisure, returns to California where he becomes a lumber baron up around Mendocino. His obituary, in 1942, doesn’t mention the assault or the arrest, and says that he never married. We know better.

But, back to Paul Hines.

circa 1900

Paul Hines

It’s unclear what job Hines held in 1897, but I’m guessing that Howe Totten was grateful that Hines intervened, was instrumental in subduing Scooffy, and was the one who pried the gun away before Schooffy could shoot.

I mean, I would be pretty grateful if someone stopped someone from shooting me. I’d want to thank that person. Wouldn’t you?

Howe Totten and his father were prominent DC lawyers. And, Howe Totten’s grandfather? That was Senator Timothy Howe, who was once offered – and turned down – the position of Chief Justice of the United States and was later named Postmaster General.

In gratitude, could Howe Totten been the one who helped Hines land his postmaster job, perhaps pulling some strings or putting a good word in with the President?

Like I said yesterday, there’s a lot of blurriness surrounding Paul Hines.

And, while we can’t unblur everything, we can say this …

Paul Hines, the player who made baseball’s first unassisted triple play, was a hero that day.

And, it’s a shame that he’s not remembered for it.

Read Part 1 of Paul Hines’ story here.

Read more from the Virginia-Born Baseball Project here.

Thank you to JJ whose comment yesterday spurred me to dig a little deeper.

11 thoughts on “Paul Hines:  A Little More To Unspool

  1. Pingback: Paul Hines, Baseball Player: The Unblurrification | The Baseball Bloggess

  2. Thanks for the follow-up and (some) clarification, Bloggess.
    “Leonidas Scooffy?” Really? Why are people not given names like that, any more? I have GOT to bestow that moniker on something, or someone, soon. My car, my next cat, my… something. The name must not die!
    As always, thanks, and be well. -J.

    • And, John … he was a lumber baron in your neck of the woods … from San Francisco up to Fort Bragg. So yes, Scooffy it up! (His last name was spelled a zillion different ways in the reports at the time, but the California papers were all consistent that his name was Leonidas Scooffy.)

  3. Once again, truth is shown to be stranger than fiction. This is “dime novel“ worthy, with the bonus of validity! I can’t help but feel that Hines would have been a media sensation had all this occurred in the Roaring 20s

  4. Fascinating! Thank you for bringing the life of Paul Hines to our attention. It’s astounding how much he accomplished, despite being deaf and having his triple play discounted/forgotten.
    Someone should make a movie! Seems like he couldn’t stay out of the news, even after he had retired from baseball. Imagine if he had lived in today’s times with social media, etc!

  5. You are a master of mystery solving! Even if there are still some unanswered questions about Hines, you have brought him back to life and light. Thank you.

Say "Hey" ...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.