Some Things Should Stay The Same: 1857 Edition

Photo by Ylanite Koppens on

We’re taking a holiday sidetrack through 1857 today — from baseball to one of the most ubiquitous Christmas Carols.

On Christmas Day when I was a kid, my dad would take all the wrapped gifts marked for him and line them up in front of his chair. He would then randomly pick one and declare that it was the best of all. And, that was the gift he would open last. And, by last, I mean later in the day. Much later. Sometimes he would save that last gift until well into the evening when mom was already thinking about taking down the tree. (Mom usually had the Christmas tree stripped and down by lunchtime on the 26th.)

Throughout Christmas Day, my dad would ask if I had any more packages to open, and when I would sadly answer “no,” he would pick up his gift and say, “I still have one to open and it’s the best.”

The Baseball Bloggess grabbing for just one more gift.

So, stick with me because the best story I will tell you today will be the one I tell last.

First, baseball.

If you want to snoop through all the stories of baseball – or “base ball” or “base-ball” – in newspapers in 1857, it won’t take long. A couple dozen mentions are all you will find.

When this peculiar, relatively new game appears in Bloomington, Indiana in June 1857, the local paper reports:

“It is a lively and exciting game, with lots of exercise and fun in it. We hope it will speedily become popular here.”

It was, they said, a game for young men. And, with life expectancy hovering around 38 back then, pretty much everything was for young men. (Sorry, ladies, no baseball for you.)

1857 was also a landmark year in baseball’s evolution. In February, a “Base Ball Convention” was held in New York, where an assortment of leaders from various New York base ball leagues met to agree on, and standardize, some of the rules of the game.

It is at this convention in 1857 that the leagues agreed on things like this:

  • A game would be nine innings. (Games tied after nine would continue.)
  • A caught fly ball would be an out. But, if the ball bounced before being caught, the play would be fair.
  • The bat must be round.
  • There must be four – and only four – bases, including home, and each base must be spaced 90 feet from the next.
  • A base runner cannot run outside the base paths.
  • A team is allowed three outs in its half of the inning.

And, look, here we are 162 years later, and we’re still playing by pretty much the same rules. (You can read the entire 1857 final document here.)

Sure, some things have changed. But, nine innings? Some things are fine just the way they were in 1857.

Which brings me to Christmas.

Photo by fotografierende on

In Baltimore, on Christmas Day 1857, the Holliday Street Theatre presented their “Christmas Gala!” with an evening performance, and “Afternoon Entertainment for Ladies and Children.”

The Baltimore Sun, 12/25/1857

“the beautiful Drama of The Hunchback of Notre Dame;


The Maniac Mother!”

There was also a performance at The Baltimore Museum – “expressly for the children” – of something called Laugh and Grow Fat!

If The Maniac Mother! wasn’t your idea of entertainment, just 25 cents would get you into Sanderson’s Gigantic Representation of the Late Russian War at the Maryland Institute, including a display of the war on 50,000 feet of canvas.

The Baltimore Sun, 12/25/1857

“Once Seen, Never To Be Forgotten!


Well, you could swing by the Canton Hotel where they’ll be shooting 100 turkeys for Christmas.

The Baltimore Sun, 12/25/1857

And, yes, people gave Christmas gifts back in 1857. (Things other than 100 dead turkeys.)

“Suitable Holiday Presents,” including beaver and velvet cloaks, were still available at Hamilton’s and Co. on Christmas morning.

Really, to read the ads – “suitable” about sums up Christmas presents in 1857.  Clothes or gloves. If you were lucky, maybe some raisins. Or if you were a really, really lucky kid, a hobby horse “on which the boy may propel himself with pleasure.” (Sorry, girls, no hobby horse for you.)

And, there were Christmas carols back then, too.

(Like the gift my dad saved until last, here’s the part I’ve been saving for you.)

In 1857, James Pierpont published a song he called The One Horse Open Sleigh, the song we know today as Jingle Bells.

Public Domain

James Lord Pierpont

Pierpont wrote plenty of less-famous songs. Songs like The Returned Californian. The Gold Rush had lured the Massachusetts native to abandon his wife and children and head to California a few years earlier. Things clearly didn’t go well:

Oh, I’m going far away from my Creditors just now,
I ain’t the tin to pay ’em and they’re kicking up a row;
I ain’t one of those lucky ones that works for ‘Uncle Sam,’
There’s no chance for speculation and the mines ain’t worth a damn.

There’s my tailor vowing vengeance and he swears he’ll give me Fitts,
And Sheriff’s running after me with pockets full of writs;
And which ever way I turn, I am sure to meet a dun,
So I guess the best thing I can do, is just to cut and run.

From California, Pierpont ended up in Georgia and that’s where he is when he publishes The One Horse Open Sleigh in 1857. (Massachusetts and Georgia have been tussling for more than a century about who gets credit for the song.)

(Pierpont later wrote Civil War-era songs for the Confederacy, including Our Battle Flag, Strike for the South, and We Conquer or Die.)

But, back to Jingle Bells. Because the song we sing today is not the song he wrote.

Public Domain

His original lyrics are a little different, racy, even. (“Go it while you’re young” is clearly 1857-style soft porn.)

But, it’s not that.

It’s the melody.

Somewhere along the way some know-it-all decided to tweak the chorus’ melody. Some people think it was to make it easier to sing. But, that tweak turned the song into the dull and insipid version we all have heard about a billion too many times.

And, that’s a shame.

Because, like nine-inning baseball games, some things should stay the way 1857 made them.

And, Jingle Bells is one of them.

Here it is. The better Jingle Bells. The real Jingle Bells.

Don’t ever sing it to me the wrong way again.

Happy Holidays!

8 thoughts on “Some Things Should Stay The Same: 1857 Edition

  1. Blogess, allow me take this occasion to thank you for all that you do, throughout the year. You write about far more than Baseball, and I never come away from one of your essays without some bit of fresh and useful knowledge. Your subject is, actually, Americana, with Baseball as the unifying factor, consistently interesting, if usually just a little bit… well, wonky. Just the way I like it.
    So, thanks, and I look forward to shared excitement, as Spring Training creeps closer. The Giants are in full rebuild mode this year, so absolutely anything can happen- Just the way it should be.
    Be well.
    Ps: How are the Orioles looking this year? For your sake (and because I love the older, “traditional” teams), I care. -J.

    • John, Thank you so much for the kind words. Yes, I think that baseball is so much more than a game, so I always enjoy finding the interesting bits beyond the nine innings. Good luck to your Giants — they seem to be rebuilding in a thoughtful way! The Orioles are setting up for another bad season — but we fans are promised that if we trust the process it will all work out … eventually … some day. So, I’m preparing myself for 100 losses … and finding joy in there somewhere, I guess, will be my New Year’s Resolution! :)

  2. I rather like the original chorus—it’s better for harmonizing, I think. Merry Christmas to you! Here’s hoping Santa will leave a pitching ace and a coupla’ big bats for your Os!

  3. Thanks Bloggess for another delightful look at the past. Except for Jingle Bells, the other forms of entertainment seem almost grizzly. Life must have been challenging for those films and reproductions of war to be considered enjoyable. I think I will take life today and be more thankful for it. Happy New Year!

  4. Pingback: Winter 2020 At Peaceful Hands — Plus, Yoga On New Year’s Day | Peaceful Hands Massage & Yoga

Say "Hey" ...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.